LCA Use Phase Losses & Microfiber Pollution

LCA frequently examines the life cycle of various products for which the production phase appears to carry the largest share of environmental burdens. However, we often assume in our models that the product’s material mass remains to the product’s end-of-life (EOL) phase. At EOL management, the material product is then usually modeled as a split between recycling, landfilling, and incineration with and without energy recovery. Often—not always but often, the use and EOL phase burdens are dwarfed by those of the production phase. However, in many material product systems, it also may be relevant to account for dissipative material losses occurring in the use phase. A recent example in the environmental news is that of microfiber release from synthetic textiles such as nylon, polyester, and acrylic, e.g., in apparel product systems. Some synthetic textiles are even composed of plastics recovered from the EOL of other product systems in an attempt to reduce overall plastic waste. From these material lifecycles, plastic microfibers can be released during the use phase, for example, at each product wash cycle. Much of the plastic microfiber release escapes wastewater treatment technologies. For a single product use, the amount of microfiber released is negligible, but collectively this phenomenon is affecting both marine and freshwater on a massive scale. In fact, synthetic microfibers are easily mistaken as food by marine fauna and so can end up on our dinner plates.

Where should system boundaries be drawn to reflect this issue in modeling and at which point should correction occur? Do we include upstream plastic products from which EOL materials are recovered and converted to synthetic fibers? For laundered textiles, should manufacturers of washing machines install new filtering devices and retrofit existing equipment? Will users become sufficiently aware and make new decisions about their textile material origins? Should wastewater treatment plants update technology to account for microfiber pollution? These are the important questions for relevant stakeholders in society. Meanwhile, as LCA analysts, this example should be referenced as we improve our assessment of use phase losses in all product systems. We can more carefully consider the physical potential and nature of dissipative use-phase material loss in various product systems by: considering scenario analysis for existing and potential technologies, considering market changes which might affect these scenarios, and updating our quantitative modeling methodologies to reflect a more steady-state approach (see example study: Improved algorithms for LCI modeling of reusable packaging).

Nanotech & LCA: The Shape We Are In:

LCA studies of nanotechnologies are increasingly important as nanomaterials are becoming widespread in consumer products. It is inevitable that nanoparticles will interact with organisms during their production, use, recovery, and/or disposal. With the lack of data from long-term studies, analysts must make hypothetical assumptions and examine a large range of potential outcomes to model these interactions in the life cycle context. As an example, see the 2014 OECD work to which I contributed, LCA on nanotechnology and vehicle tires.

Recent research summarized in an article in Environmental Science Nano is contributing to our increasing pool of knowledge on nanoparticle interactions in the environment. This research indicates that nanoparticle shapes can have a significant effect on nanoparticle interactions with organisms. There are several variables for how differently shaped nanoparticles interact at organism membranes and these may not be generalizable across all biological systems. However, authors conclude that particle shape be considered at the design phase of useful and sustainable nanomaterials.

Buchman JT, Gallagher MJ, Yang C, Zhang X, Krause MOP, Hernandez R, Orr G (2016). Research highlights: examining the effect of shape on nanoparticle interactions with organisms, Environmental Science Nano, 3:696-700.

TranSustainable Enterprises Launched!

TranSustainable Enterprises (TE) is founded in Fall 2015 by independent consultant Rebe Feraldi. TE is an owner-operated, Limited Liability Company aiming to provide expert advice on life cycle inventory (LCI) and life cycle assessment (LCA) methodologies for science-based decision making. I would like to work on short- or long-term contracts and research assignments with a range of clients including private, industrial, governmental, and non-governmental. I have experience with numerous LCI databases and software platforms. Please see the ABOUT and QUALIFICATIONS pages for more information.